India’s Chief of Defence Staff, General NS Raja Subramani, told a security conference in Delhi on Monday that when “Starlink was denied or degraded, Ukrainian long-range drones lost their efficacy” — his case for why India must build satellite capabilities it controls itself. He was speaking at the ANI National Security Summit 3.0, according to Open Magazine and Oneindia, both working from news agency ANI’s wire copy; neither outlet published a full transcript or video of the address.
Key facts
- General Raja Subramani said space is already a key enabler of modern warfare and will be increasingly contested, with adversaries trying to deny India the use of space, Oneindia reported.
- He cited Ukraine, where he said the denial or degradation of Starlink — SpaceX’s satellite internet network, which delivers broadband from satellites in low Earth orbit rather than over ground cable — cost Ukrainian long-range drones their effectiveness.
- He called for self-reliant space capacity built with both the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO), India’s national space agency, and commercial private players, per Open Magazine.
- He said India has launched Space-Based Surveillance-3 (SBS-3) and that the system will deliver significant capability once fully launched, but that India needs more reliable intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (ISR), communications and precision navigation and timing.
- Three companies — Reliance Jio’s Jio Satcom, Bharti-backed Eutelsat OneWeb and Starlink — hold satellite communications licences in India, Oneindia reported.
Why it matters
A dispute that has so far run between Kyiv, Washington and SpaceX is now being cited by a third government in its own force planning. The general’s argument, by his own account of Ukraine, is about authority rather than bandwidth: what grounded the drones was the network being switched down, not a gap in its coverage.
That maps onto the fight already under way inside India over where a foreign operator’s shutdown controls should sit. Bharti chairman Sunil Mittal has said Starlink can come in provided any kill switch stays local, and Starlink says it is ready to begin service once approvals land. What the CDS adds is a defence rationale for a demand that has until now been pressed on commercial and regulatory grounds — and he made it while naming military communications and surveillance as capabilities India still lacks.
What the CDS said
Space was one of five areas he named for India’s preparedness for future wars, Open Magazine reported, alongside algorithmic and data warfare, defence manufacturing, modernisation of legacy systems and the development of human talent. He said artificial intelligence would play a key role in warfare, with data, computing power, energy and access to talent as its enablers.
On manufacturing, he said it was not enough for Indian industry to assemble complete systems: the country needs to make critical components such as servos, magnetometers and sensors itself, or at least hold the intellectual property and technology to make them at scale.
What happened to Starlink in Ukraine
Ukrainian officials said on 14 October that restrictions affecting SpaceX’s satellite communications were disrupting drone operations amid daily Russian air attacks, according to TIME. Ukraine relies on Starlink for frontline communications, drone capabilities and reconnaissance, and officials said the throttled connection led to the cancellation of several missions.
The restrictions also hit Starshield, a military-grade satellite communications service that uses Starlink technology but is supplied through US government contracts, TIME reported. Ukraine’s Defence Ministry said on 24 October that both services had been fully restored, with connections stable even on terminals moving at speeds above 400 km/h, according to the same report, carried also by AOL. Ukraine’s defence minister, Yevheniy Khmara, said a strong and stable connection was vital for the front line, for drones, and for logistics and communications.
Who acted, and why, is disputed. SpaceX chief executive Elon Musk said the Ukrainian military had violated Starlink’s terms of service and that SpaceX restricted the network to prevent that alleged misuse; Ukrainian officials rejected that account, TIME reported. SpaceX has separately attributed the Starshield limits to a technical issue.
Alex Crowther, an adjunct professor at Florida International University’s Jack D. Gordon Institute for Public Policy, told TIME the unresolved point is which party holds the authority to switch the service on and off — Starlink as a private company, Starshield as a US government contract, Musk, US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth or President Donald Trump. Contracts with American companies usually spell that out, he said.
India’s licensing backdrop
General Raja Subramani’s comments come as Starlink’s entry into India remains unresolved. The sequence, as reported by Oneindia and Open Magazine:
- Last month Musk questioned the delay in final approvals, writing on X that Starlink is licensed in more than 165 countries and has spent five years complying with Indian requirements, and accusing unnamed oligarchs of protecting a monopoly.
- India’s Ministry of Communications rejected that, saying the suggestion that the regulatory framework or its application is unfair or discriminatory has no basis.
- The government’s stated position is that India welcomes all players and that consumers will choose providers on price, value and quality.
- Rules for spectrum allocation and pricing are still being finalised.
Background: the 2022 Kherson report
Monday’s remarks were not the first account of Starlink coverage being curtailed in Ukraine.
Oneindia cited a Reuters investigation which reported that Musk ordered a disruption of coverage in parts of Ukraine during a counteroffensive against Russian forces in September 2022, affecting areas including Kherson. At least 100 terminals were reportedly deactivated.
A Ukrainian military official told Reuters that an attempt to encircle Russian forces near Beryslav stalled entirely.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who controls changes to Starshield — SpaceX or the US government?
Musk maintains that the United States government, not SpaceX, controls changes to Starshield, according to TIME.
Who ordered the October restrictions on Ukraine’s service?
That remains unresolved. TIME reported that a Reuters report of 15 October cited multiple officials who said the order came from inside the White House, without naming who authorised or implemented it, while a senior US official denied it was President Donald Trump. Trump himself declined to identify those involved.
Why can Starlink not sell service in India yet?
Oneindia reports that holding a licence alone does not permit commercial operations in India. Companies must first meet mandatory security requirements and obtain spectrum-related approvals.
Could Ukraine simply switch to another satellite provider?
Not easily, according to Lance Hunter, a professor of political science at Augusta University, who told TIME that Starlink technology is not something a government can reproduce domestically and that few providers worldwide offer comparable capabilities. He said Starlink has a monopoly on that technology to a degree on speed, availability and flexibility, and that European countries and private firms do not match it.












