India’s Chief of Defence Staff, General NS Raja Subramani, told the ANI National Security Summit 3.0 in Delhi that the disruption of Starlink services during the Ukraine conflict shows why the country needs space capabilities it controls itself. The News Mill dates the remarks to November 16.
Key facts
- The CDS said space has already become a key enabler of modern warfare and will be increasingly contested, with adversaries trying to deny access to it.
- He cited Ukraine, where he said the denial or degradation of Starlink — SpaceX’s low-Earth-orbit broadband network — cost Ukrainian long-range drones their effectiveness.
- He said India has launched Space-Based Surveillance-3 (SBS-3) and needs to expand beyond it for reliable intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, communications and precision navigation and timing.
- Three companies — Jio, OneWeb and Starlink — hold licences in India’s satellite communications sector, and all three must still meet prescribed security requirements before commercial service.
- The framework for spectrum allocation and pricing is still being finalised; neither report gives a completion date.
- The government’s position, as both outlets put it, is that India welcomes all players and that consumers will choose providers on pricing, value and quality.
Why it matters
A licence is not a launch. For anyone tracking Starlink availability in India, the wait now turns on two things outside SpaceX’s control: a security clearance it has to be granted, and a spectrum regime the government has yet to publish.
The CDS’s point is separate, and it is about dependence rather than cost: a commercial satellite link used in an operational role can be switched off by someone else, which is his argument for building Indian capacity alongside commercial suppliers.
What the CDS said about Ukraine
General Raja Subramani used Ukraine as a cautionary example of how reliance on an external satellite communications system can affect military operations, according to Devdiscourse. “An example of which we can see in Ukraine when Starlink was denied or degraded, Ukrainian long-range drones lost their efficacy,” he said, in the version carried by The News Mill.
Neither report identifies who denied or degraded the service, when it happened, or what mechanism was involved. The remark follows a run of related coverage, including India’s defence chief cites Starlink denial in Ukraine.
His remedy was domestic capacity on two tracks: self-reliant space capability built with ISRO, India’s space agency, and with commercial private players.
One small difference between the reports on SBS-3
Devdiscourse quotes the CDS saying the system will give India great capability “once SBS 3 is fully launched”, while The News Mill describes the benefit as arriving once the system is fully operational. Neither gives a date, a satellite count or a cost.
Spectrum, clearances and the missing price
On timing, neither outlet offers one. The spectrum allocation and pricing framework is described only as “being finalised”, with no target date for the rules and no expected window for commercial service to begin — so the licence holders’ own start dates remain open.
On price, the figure readers want does not exist in either account. What is unsettled is spectrum pricing — what operators pay the government for airwaves — not a retail tariff, and neither report publishes a number, a range or a benchmark against markets where Starlink already sells. Until the spectrum charge is set, the licence holders cannot cost their own service, which is one reason no Indian subscription price has been announced. SpaceX’s own view of its readiness, and Reliance’s objections, are set out in Starlink says it is ready for India as Reliance hits back.
The licensing backdrop
The comments arrive during an ongoing debate over Starlink’s proposed entry into the Indian market, both reports say. They add that SpaceX chief executive Elon Musk has raised concerns over alleged attempts to obstruct the company’s commercial operations in the country; neither source details those allegations or names anyone accused.
One of the rival licence holders is already looking past the current rules: Jio’s parent is pursuing its own constellation, as covered in Ambani’s plan for 1,600 satellites.
Beyond space, the CDS listed four other national priorities — algorithmic and data warfare, defence manufacturing, modernisation of legacy systems and human talent — none of which bear on satellite broadband licensing.
About the sourcing
Both accounts of the speech come from the same summit, and no transcript or official release of the CDS’s remarks has been published that this report has seen. Where the two differ, the difference is noted above.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much will Starlink cost in India?
No consumer price has been announced in either report. The only pricing either outlet mentions is the government’s spectrum pricing framework — the charge operators pay for airwaves — and neither gives a figure, a range or a comparison with other markets.
Did the defence chief say who degraded Starlink in Ukraine?
No. General Raja Subramani spoke in general terms about adversaries trying to deny the use of space; neither account names a party, a date or a mechanism.
Is the CDS asking India to keep Starlink out?
Neither report says so. His stated remedy was building Indian capability with ISRO and private industry alongside commercial suppliers, not restricting them.
Are Devdiscourse and The News Mill independent accounts?
They are two separate write-ups of the same speech at the same event, with near-identical detail. No official transcript or press release for the remarks has been published that this report has seen, so every fact here rests on those two summaries.














Comments 1